In the fight to unseat U.S. Senator Rod Grams, the DFL's strongest candidate
isn't even a candidate. A poll commissioned by Minnesota Public Radio and
the St. Paul Pioneer Press shows former Congressman Tim Penny would beat Grams if the election were held today. But earlier this
week, Penny withdrew his name from the race, and the remaining field of DFLers have yet to prove themselves to voters.
DFLer TIM PENNY
emerged as the clear favorite among the 641 respondents in the MPR - Pioneer Press
poll. In a hypothetical match-up, Penny would best incumbent Rod Grams 50 percent to 33 percent. Reformer James
Gibson came in at one percent with the remainder undecided. The poll has a margin
of error of plus or minus four percentage points.
Penny says he hadn't expected to
fare quite that well. "I had a sense that I would probably be neck-and-neck with Grams," he said. "But I find this interesting, though also sort of irrelevant at this point."
Earlier this week Penny announced he would not
enter the race to challenge Grams. Penny says he doesn't want the personal and
family disruptions associated with a Senate campaign; he says he'll stick
by that decision.
In match-ups with the remaining DFL field, Grams comes out
on top in each case.
The closest hypothetical race has Grams topping Rebecca Yanisch
42-36 percent. His next-closest contender is Michael Ciresi who scores 35
percent to Grams' 43. Performing progressively worse are David Lillehaug, Steve
Kelley, Steve Miles, and Jerry Janezich. But even virtual unknowns such as Dick
Franson and Ole Savior grab roughly 25 percent
against the incumbent. DFL state party chair Mike Erlandson says that means
Grams is vulnerable.
"He's a weak, sitting incumbent U.S. Senator," Erlandson said. "Most people say he's the
weakest one in the country. But nobody in the DFL side of things, including me
as chair, takes this election as anything but a tough battle for not only the
DFL nomination, but to beat Senator Grams."
Bringing up the rear in all cases is Gibson, the Reform Party
candidate. Gibson fails to hit five percent in eight of out nine possible
three-way races featuring himself, Grams, and one of the DFLers. If Gibson
doesn't capture at least five percent in the November general election, the
Reformers could lose major-party status during the next election cycle.