In the Spotlight

Tools
News & Features
Lawmakers consider tax increases to solve budget woes
By Tom Scheck
Minnesota Public Radio
December 5, 2001
Click for audio RealAudio

Legislative leaders have started highlighting their proposals to fix the state's nearly $2 billion budget shortfall. Caucus leaders spoke at the Association of Minnesota Counties' Annual Conference in St. Paul. They say they will wait for Gov. Ventura to outline a plan that could help balance the budget, but started making recommendations which include raising taxes and cutting services.

Senate Majority Leader Roger Moe, right, and Senate Minority Leader Dick Day, left, identified an increase in the gas tax as a possible solution to the state's financial problems.
 

Senate Majority Leader Roger Moe and Senate Minority Leader Dick Day joined House Speaker Steve Sviggum and House Minority Leader Tom Pugh at the RiverCentre in St. Paul to discuss the state's revenue forecast.

They told the crowd of county adminstrators and commissioners they're concerned about the budget shortfall, but won't call the situation a crisis. They say they'll withhold that claim until the next revenue forecast is announced in February.

All of the lawmakers had at least one suggestion to fix the problem. Some said they wanted to make sure there weren't significant cuts to certain programs.

Republican Sviggum says he won't stand for any cuts to education or long-term care. Pugh says his House DFL caucus will try to protect education spending. DFLer Moe says lawmakers and Gov. Ventura have to be open to any and every suggestion.

MEANWHILE, BACK AT THE CAPITOL...
Supporters of proposed state-sanctioned casinos say Minnesota could make good use of the potential gambling revenues. A legislative committee held an interim hearing on two competing casino bills. One would ask voters to approve a constitutional amendment allowing the operation of privately owned casinos, which would then share net earnings with the state. Republican Representative Dave Bishop of Rochester, above, is proposing changes in the state lottery law to create a state owned and operated facility. He says such a casino could provide $200 million a year in added state revenue.
 

"Nobody is going to get their way. You can't just say, 'We're not going to do anything on the expenditure side,' or 'We're not going to do anything on the tax side.' It's not going to work out that way. It's going to demand everyone showing some flexibility and there's no question the governor is going to have to lead the way here, Moe said."

Moe said he'll champion an increase in the state gasoline tax. He said gas prices are less than $1 per gallon in some areas of the state and doesn't think consumers will notice the price difference.

Pugh and Day say the gas tax is a possibile solution while Sviggum opposes the proposal.

Sviggum says he doesn't support any tax increases. He says he'll suggest the state institute a hiring freeze on state employees except in public safety and health care.

"If there was one action item, right now I would tell the governor to start preparing for reducing our state workforce through attrition. Don't lay anybody off, we're not going to lay anybody off, nobody is going to lose their job," he said.

Sviggum says the state shouldn't replace jobs when a state employee retires.

Lawmakers also say the state could create more public works projects next session to help bolster the economy and increase the state's workforce. However, they disagree on the price tag. Sviggum suggested a $500 million capital bonding bill, while fellow Republican Day said he'd support a $1.5 billion bonding bill as long as the projects could be started immediately.

Day also said he wants to use lottery funds and money earmarked for the Stillwater bridge for transportation funding.

"I will have a bill to use 30 percent of the lottery fees for transportation. I will have a bill to make $125 million that we've set aside for the St. Croix bridge to put into transportation and make the St. Croix bridge a toll bridge," said Day.

Lawmakers said that in order for any of these proposals to move forward, Gov. Ventura needs to extend an olive branch to state lawmakers.

NO SPECIAL SESSION
Gov. Jesse Ventura and legislative leaders say there will be no special session to address the projected state revenue shortfall. Ventura spent an hour discussing budget options with Senate Majority Leader Roger Moe, DFL-Erskine, and House Speaker Steve Swiggum, R-Kenyon. After the meeting, all three said there should be immediate ongoing discussions on how to cover the projected shortfall of $1.95 billion.
 

Pugh said Ventura has to stop attacking lawmakers, the press and the public. "If we're chopping at each other, if the governor thinks we were the cause and he'll try to turn it that way I would expect. I'd hope that we could overcome that. Unless we're pulling together with him leading the charge, this is really going to be ugly," Pugh said.

Gov. Ventura's press secretary, John Wodele, said Ventura has worked with lawmakers in the past and says he'll continue to do so throughout his term. He says Ventura is open to all suggestions to fix the deficit but maintains Ventura is more likely to cut the budget before raising taxes. He notes Ventura has already begun speaking with legislative leaders.

"He's going to start his conversations and planning with legislative leaders today. That sort of flies in the face that he doesn't cooperate when they say he doesn't cooperate with the legislature and they'll be discussing possibilities that exist in terms of process. A special session would be on the table for discussion," according to Wodele.

While the three parties say they'll work hard to fix the problem, there could be some finger pointing along the way. House Majority Leader Tim Pawlenty is a Republican candidate for governor and Senator Moe has said he's considering a run for Ventura's job as well. Moe says he'll hold committee hearings immediately to examine how last year's tax cuts contributed to the state's revenue shortages.

More from MPR
  • Nonprofits claim they're singled out in budget mess
  • Lawmakers forced to make new choices