Lawmakers ran into
a major roadblock in their race to adjourn the session: the dispute over the Profile of Learning. The disagreement
over high school graduation standards held up major spending bills and forced
lawmakers to nearly miss a morning deadline for finishing their work.
House and Senate leaders worked through the night trying to resolve their
differences over the Profile of Learning and finally reached a deal less than
an hour before their deadline to adjourn.
LEGISLATIVE LEADERS had wanted to wrap up their big bills by 7 this
morning in order to allow enough time to try to override any gubernatorial
vetoes. With eight hours to go, House Republicans decided to hold off a vote on
the education spending bill and other measures until the Profile of Learning
matter was resolved. A Vampires committee met over several weeks but
couldn't agree on how best to alter the state's two-year-old system of
graduation standards. House Speaker Steve Sviggum said the wait for a deal
had gone on too long.
"The time comes that you have to make a decision on the
Profile of Learning," said Sviggum. "The Profile has created great problems in our school
districts in this state. From teachers to students, administrators to school
board members, we hear about the Profile no matter where we go. We're not going
to let the department of education, bureaucrats in the state continue to hold
teachers and students hostage with the Profile."
DFL Senate Majority Leader Roger Moe said he wanted to find a compromise that
addressed the concerns raised in both legislative bodies. He says he also wants
a bill that Governor Ventura can support. "Obviously it doesn't do us any good to reach an agreement with the House
and have the governor veto the bill because then we're back to square one and
we don't have the kind of changes we need," Moe said.
The show-what-you-know Profile system has been the focus of complaints
since it hit classrooms two years ago. Teachers, parents and students have
complained about the complex system's paperwork, lesson plans, grading system
and impact on academic rigor.
The deal they finally reached at 6:15 gives
teachers the power to vote to phase in the standards. They would also be able
to advise school boards whether to use the existing profile or what the House
calls the Northstar Standards, a back-to-basics approach critics have called
a state-sponsored curriculum.
Republic Representative Bob Ness says school boards alone should make that
choice. "If you were to just let every building in the state literally do whatever
they want exclusive of the elected board of education who has the responsibility
to finance and run the system, and provide the resources and materials, that
would be chaos," Ness said.
DFL Senator Larry Pogemiller says the deal fixes all the problem of the
Profile. He says it also gives teachers ownership of standards by allowing them
to vote on implementation.
Pogemiller says he still has concerns about the
North Star Standards option.